Annals of Justice and Humanity

Annals of Justice and Humanity (AJH) is an international peer-reviewed and scholarly journal aimed at publicizing solutive and innovative ideas of researchers, practitioners, and academicians in addressing interesting legal issues and encouraging the development of legal studies. AJH welcomes submissions of high-quality and well-developed research manuscripts on wide range fields related to law science.

Current Issue

Annals of Justice and Humanity (AJH) is an international peer-reviewed and scholarly journal aimed at publicizing solutive and innovative ideas of researchers, practitioners, and academicians in addressing interesting legal issues and encouraging the development of legal studies. AJH welcomes submissions of high-quality and well-developed research manuscripts on wide range fields related to law science.

Published
2025-12-02

Articles

Juridical analysis of land rights release with ownership certificates purchased by limited liability companies from land law perspective

Purpose: This study aims to analyze the legal framework for the release of Freehold Title (SHM) land purchased by Limited Liability Companies (PT) in Batam. It focuses on the regulatory basis, implementation practices, and the challenges and solutions in the conversion process to Right to Build (HGB). Methodology: The research employs a descriptive sociological-juridical method combined with a normative legal approach to examine secondary data, and an empirical approach to gather primary data through field research. The analysis integrates statutory interpretation and practical observations from stakeholders. Results: Findings reveal that SHM land purchased by a PT must first be released and transferred to the state before being converted to HGB. The process involves drafting a deed of release before a notary, fulfilling BP Batam’s regulatory requirements, and submitting an HGB application to BPN under Minister of ATR/BPN Regulation No. 5 of 2025. Conclusion: The legal certainty of land release in Batam depends on technical regulations, institutional coordination, and digital integration. While the current system provides a mechanism, procedural and administrative delays persist. Limitations:The study is limited to the Batam context and relies on selected field data. Broader generalization may require comparative studies across other special economic zones in Indonesia. Contribution: This research contributes to the discourse on land law reform in Indonesia by offering practical legal solutions, including the need for technical regulations on release deeds, improved inter-agency coordination, and digital land information systems to ensure efficiency and certainty in land rights conversion.

Juridical analysis of the application of the code of ethics to notaries who commit occupational violations

Purpose: This study aims to analyze the legal arrangements governing the Notary code of ethics in Indonesia, particularly in Tanjungpinang City, examine its practical application in cases of office violations, and identify the obstacles and solutions in enforcing professional discipline. Methodology: The study applies normative and empirical juridical approaches, using legal reviews of the Notary Position Law and INI Code of Ethics, supported by interviews, documentation, and field observations of supervisory practices by the Regional Supervisory Assembly and the INI Honor Council in Tanjungpinang City. Results: The study finds that although notarial ethical regulations are comprehensive, practical enforcement remains inconsistent due to persistent violations, low ethical awareness, weak coordination, and limited public legal literacy. Conclusions: The enforcement of the notarial code of ethics in Tanjungpinang City is still suboptimal despite sufficient normative frameworks. Effective enforcement requires strengthening institutional coordination, raising public awareness, and conducting periodic evaluations of ethical regulations. Limitations: This research is geographically limited to Tanjungpinang City and primarily focuses on current supervisory mechanisms. Broader comparative studies across different regions could provide deeper insights into systemic issues in notarial supervision. Contribution: The study contributes to the discourse on professional accountability in the notarial field by highlighting the gap between normative regulation and empirical practice. It also provides recommendations for improving institutional oversight and public legal awareness, thereby enhancing legal certainty and professional integrity in notarial services.

Juridical analysis of legal protection for the implementation of option agreements for foreign citizens (foreign nationals) in apartment ownership (research study: Apartments in Batam City

Purpose: This study examines the legal protection of option agreements used by foreign nationals (FNs) to acquire apartment ownership in Batam City. It evaluates the regulatory framework, practical implementation, challenges, and the extent to which such agreements provide legal certainty for both developers and FNs. Methodology: A normative juridical approach was combined with a socio-legal method. Secondary data were obtained from legislation, legal literature, and jurisprudence, while primary data were gathered through interviews with notaries, government officials, developers, and foreign buyers in Batam. Results: The findings reveal that option agreements, though widely applied, lack explicit regulation in Indonesian law. Their legal force relies on the contractual freedom principle under the Civil Code, making them valid but weak in providing ownership rights. In practice, they are often used as alternatives to bypass restrictions on foreign ownership, but this creates potential legal uncertainty, especially in cases of default, regulatory changes, or disputes. Conclusion: Option agreements serve only as contractual instruments and fail to provide comprehensive legal protection or full ownership rights for FNs under Indonesian agrarian law. Clearer statutory provisions are required to enhance certainty and prevent abuse. Limitations: The research is limited to Batam City and does not fully capture variations across other regions. Data on disputes and enforcement are also limited. Contribution: This study identifies regulatory gaps in option agreements and emphasizes the need for government intervention through clearer policies, offering recommendations for policymakers, land agencies, and notaries to enhance investor protection, legal certainty, and national sovereignty.

The historiographical significance of K. K. Palen’s inspection reports in the Turkestan region in 1908-1909

Purpose: This study explores the historical significance of the senatorial inspection led by Count K.K. Palen in Turkestan during 1908–1909. It aims to understand the political, economic, and cultural dynamics of the region under Russian colonial rule and assess how these reports shaped historiography on early 20th-century Central Asia. Research methodology: The research applies a qualitative historical approach through textual and historiographical analysis of Palen’s inspection reports, official records, and contemporary publications. Comparative evaluation was conducted to interpret the collected data in the context of colonial administration and regional transformation. Results: The findings reveal that the inspection exposed widespread corruption and maladministration while simultaneously producing reliable empirical data, including the only comprehensive household survey of dehkan farms in Turkestan before 1917. The reports provide valuable insights into land use, governance structures, and socio-economic changes driven by Russia’s expansionist policies. Conclusions: Palen’s reports serve as a fundamental source for reconstructing the realities of colonial Turkestan. They illustrate the duality of Russia’s civilizing mission and the exploitation of resources, offering both critical evidence of systemic flaws and documentation of modernization processes. Limitations: The inspection materials, while rich, reflect the perspectives of Russian officials and may underrepresent indigenous voices and experiences. Contribution: This study contributes to Central Asian historiography by positioning Palen’s inspection as a unique and comprehensive documentary source for analyzing governance, economic practices, and colonial discourse.

Ensuring the right to higher education: A general overview

Purpose: This study aims to examine the right to higher education as a fundamental human right and a key state obligation. It seeks to analyze international legal frameworks, national constitutions, and comparative experiences from Germany, Indonesia, Russia, and Uzbekistan to identify how legal reforms, policy mechanisms, and financial measures ensure equitable access to higher education. Methods: Using a qualitative and comparative approach, the study applies doctrinal legal analysis of primary sources such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, ICESCR, and UNESCO Conventions, alongside national education laws. Secondary data from academic research, government reports, and statistical evidence were analyzed through content analysis to evaluate legal and institutional guarantees. Results: Findings reveal that while international norms recognize higher education as a universal right, its realization varies among countries. Germany ensures free university access; Russia offers merit-based state-funded higher education; Indonesia guarantees education through constitutional budget allocation; and Uzbekistan demonstrates rapid progress through legislative reforms, expansion of institutions, and increased enrollment rates. Conclusion: Ensuring the right to higher education requires a balance between accessibility, quality, and equity through sustained state commitment and international cooperation. Limitation: The research focuses on selected case studies and does not include empirical fieldwork or student-level data, limiting its scope of generalization. Contribution: This paper contributes to comparative educational law by linking global human rights frameworks with national implementation models, providing policy insights for developing inclusive and equitable higher education systems.